2014 Academy of Management Annual Conference, Philadelphia
The study examined whether relationships between servant leadership, job satisfaction, and organizational commitment differed among Baby Boomers, Generation X, and Generation Y in a United States sample. The question was whether generational cohort membership helped explain differences in these measured relationships.
Theoretical Framework
The study utilized the Servant Leadership Survey (SLS) developed by Dirk van Dierendonck and Inge Nuijten, which includes eight dimensions: empowerment, accountability, standing back, humility, authenticity, courage, forgiveness, and stewardship.
Across the three cohorts studied, empowerment showed a strong association with job satisfaction and organizational commitment. These were relationships in survey responses, rather than evidence that a particular leadership behavior caused the outcomes.
Servant Leadership and Generational Cohorts
The study involved 452 United States participants recruited through an online research panel. They completed a 30-item servant leadership survey and measures of job satisfaction and organizational commitment. The panel sample limits how confidently the findings can be extended to employees in other populations and settings.
The analysis did not detect statistically significant differences among the three cohorts in the servant leadership and organizational outcome measures examined. This finding does not establish that the cohorts are identical or that servant leadership is equally effective in every setting.
Implications for Leadership
Within this sample, the findings gave little support for tailoring servant leadership approaches solely on the basis of generational cohort membership.
The study gives leaders reason to question broad generational stereotypes. Individual needs, the nature of the work, and organizational and country culture still require attention when choosing a leadership approach.
Practical Applications
For leaders considering servant leadership, a useful starting point is to understand how employees experience empowerment, accountability, and support in their own organization. Generational labels alone may be a weak basis for deciding what people need.
The outcomes measured here were job satisfaction and organizational commitment. The study did not establish that adopting servant leadership would increase productivity or innovation, or reduce turnover.
Conclusion
The evidence suggests that servant leadership can resonate with followers from the three cohorts represented in this United States sample. It supports further investigation of shared leadership needs across generations, while leaving effectiveness in other populations, cultures, and organizational settings to be examined.
Zimmerer, T. E., & Latham, J. R. (2014). One size fits all: Servant leadership an effective approach for all generations [Conference abstract]. Academy of Management Proceedings, 2014(1), Article 13166. https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2014.13166abstract
The download above is the full conference paper; the DOI identifies the published abstract.

